ZEE Business
ZEE BUSINESS
हिंदी में पढ़ें  हिंदी में पढ़ें
Live TV
Live TV
  • Home
  • Personal Finance
  • Adani Saga
  • Markets
    • Stocks
    • Global Markets
    • IPO
    • Companies
    • Currency
    • Commodities
  • My Money
  • Calculators
    • Income Tax Calculator
    • Home Loan/EMI Calculator
    • Mutual Fund Returns Calculator
    • Personal Loan Calculator
    • Car Loan Calculator
    • SIP calculator
    • Lumpsum Calculator
    • SWP Calculator
  • Videos
    • M Se Market
    • Jeb Zindagi Zaroorat
    • Light Camera Stocks
    • Tech Takes
    • Big Bulls Ka Nishana
    • Paisa Wasool
    • Commodity Ke MrityunjayMantra
    • The Right Property Show
  • Economy & Infra
    • Policy & Initiatives
    • Agriculture
    • Telecom
    • Aviation
    • Railways
    • Retail
    • Roadways
    • World Economy
  • Exclusive
    • Wealth Guide
    • Interviews
  • Auto
    • Cars
    • Bikes
    • Electric Vehicle
    • Commercial Vehicles
  • Tech
    • Mobiles
    • Gadgets
    • Reviews
    • Tips and Tricks
    • Apps
  • Real Estate
    • Home Buyers
    • Builders
  • Axis MF
  • Trending
    • Entertainment
    • Politics
    • Lifestyle
    • Travel
    • Sports
    • Viral
    • Education
    • Jobs
Read in App
Business News » India News

Government cannot exempt PSUs from paying their share of AGR dues, rules TDSAT; says public, private sector cannot be treated differently

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Linkedin
  • whatapp
  • View in App
Government cannot exempt PSUs from paying their share of AGR dues, rules TDSAT; says public, private sector cannot be treated differently
TDSAT) also said that an exemption can be given to public sector undertakings (PSUs) only if the same is extended to private sector players. Source: Reuters

Telecom disputes appellate tribunal TDSAT has ruled that the government cannot exempt state-owned companies from paying their share of Adjusted Gross Revenue (AGR) on the basis that they get only a small portion of their revenues from telecom-related services.

The Telecom Disputes Settlement and Appellate Tribunal (TDSAT) also said that an exemption can be given to public sector undertakings (PSUs) only if the same is extended to private sector players.

See Zee Business Live TV Streaming Below:

The order dated February 28 pertains to the more than Rs 4 lakh crore of revenue foregone by the government after the Supreme Court on October 24, 2019, dismissed telcos' petitions challenging the AGR demand by the DoT.

The TDSAT's latest ruling is on a review petition filed by Netmagic Solutions and Data Ingenious Global. The review petition was against the appellate tribunal's order -- issued on November 19, 2020 -- wherein the plea regarding exemption of PSUs from paying AGR dues was rejected, citing the apex court order dated October 24, 2019.

The latest order, by TDSAT Chairman Shiva Kirti Singh and Member Subodh Kumar Gupta, may have far-reaching consequences for the telecom sector and 13 PSUs, which have won telecom or related licences. These companies were exempted by the government from paying AGR dues.

The 13 PSUs include Oil India, Railtel Corporation, PowerGrid, Software Technology Parks of India, Noida Software Technology Parks, Gail India, Delhi Metro, ONGC, Tamil Nadu Arasu Cable TV Corporation and Gujarat Narmada Valley Fertilizers.

MTNL and BSNL were also exempted from paying the AGR dues, considering that they were government-owned entities as well as due to their weak financial conditions.

The Department of Telecommunication (DoT) had raised demand notices with respect to AGR dues.

In its 27-page order, TDSAT dismissed two of the three arguments put forth by the DoT.

The DoT argued that PSUs "form a class in themselves as they substantially discharge governmental functions and represent public funds" and, therefore, it is in "public interest to give them an exemption".

Secondly, the DoT said that revenue generated by PSUs under the head of telecom services forms a "very negligible and small part of their total revenue".

Thirdly, it said the Supreme Court judgement was given in a case about mobile service providers, and therefore it has decided to withdraw notices issued to other telecom service providers, such as internet service providers (ISPs), long-distance and bandwidth service firms and so on.

The TDSAT said public sector and private sector companies cannot be treated differently in front of the law.

"There is no scope to differentiate between two sets of licencees having same or similar licences only on the basis of their ownership, private or public. The statutory rights and liabilities must remain the same for both the classes in so far as they arise from the licences/agreements under consideration.

"The same conclusion would flow from the requirements of equality, fairness and level playing field," the appellate tribunal said.

Further, it said there is no legal basis for giving exemptions to companies generating only a small portion of their revenue from licensed services while denying it to those generating a large portion of their revenue from such activities.

"The difference in the ratio of revenue from licenced qua non-licenced activities cannot be a germane and relevant basis for change of adjusted gross revenue terms for some licencees (PSUs) and thus create

two classes amongst licencees holding the same licence," the bench said.

Regarding the argument that the apex court judgement mentioned only telcos and not ISPs and others even though they too had a similar clause in their licences, the tribunal said the DoT can restrict the scope of the apex court judgement to those holding mobile and universal access licences.

"...The impugned demands of licence fee etc raised on the petitioners by the DoT by including revenue from non-licenced activities in AGR on the basis of the judgment dated November 19, 2020, are set aside.

"The respondents will have the liberty to raise revised demands by treating the petitioners at par with the exempted PSUs having a licence to provide Internet services," the TDSAT said.

Get Latest Business News, Stock Market Updates and Videos; Check your tax outgo through Income Tax Calculator and save money through our Personal Finance coverage. Check Business Breaking News Live on Zee Business Twitter and Facebook. Subscribe on YouTube.

TAGS:
TDSATAGRMTNLBSNL
Written By: PTI
Updated: Thu, Mar 03, 2022
02:17 pm
New Delhi, PTI
RELATED NEWS
Airtel, Vodafone vs Reliance Jio: Big relief as TDSAT strikes down Trai's predatory pricing rule Airtel, Vodafone vs Reliance Jio: Big relief as TDSAT strikes down Trai's predatory pricing rule
TDSAT's interim order is a relief for telcos; they can offer value to customers: Rajan Mathews, COAI TDSAT's interim order is a relief for telcos; they can offer value to customers: Rajan Mathews, COAI
Jio case: CCI seeks probe report on telcos in 2 months Jio case: CCI seeks probe report on telcos in 2 months
Telecom Disputes Tribunal asks TRAI to re-examine Reliance Jio's promotional offers Telecom Disputes Tribunal asks TRAI to re-examine Reliance Jio's promotional offers
Telecom tribunal seeks clarifications from TRAI on Reliance Jio's free offers Telecom tribunal seeks clarifications from TRAI on Reliance Jio's free offers

LATEST NEWS

Kalyan Jewellers shares nosedive after Warburg Pincus said to have sold stakes in company at 7% discount

Samsung Galaxy A54 5G, Galaxy A34 5G price in India: Sale begins today, check discounts and offers

OPS vs NPS: Govt plans to make changes in new pension scheme on lines with old pension scheme

Cipla, Lupin, Glenmark other pharma stocks stuck in narrow range after NPPA revises price of 25 drug formulations

Rising Covid cases may lead to surge in hospitalisation, ICU stays: Doctors

How GPT4 is different from ChatGPT or GPT3.5 - All you need to know

TRAI holds meeting with telecom firms over unsolicited calls; shares mixed

Avatar: The Way of Water OTT release date confirmed: James Cameron's directorial to release on these platforms

Zydus Lifesciences shares surge on USFDA nod for generic drug

Sebi extends nomination deadline for demat account holders to September 30, check details here

  • India News
  • World News
  • Companies News
  • Market News
  • Personal Finance News
  • Technology News
  • Automobile News
  • Small Business News
  • Income Tax Calculator
  • Live TV
  • Videos
  • Photos
  • Author
  • Rss Feed
  • Advertise with us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Legal Disclaimer

Latest Trending Updates

  • EPFO
  • Budget 2020
  • Income Tax Return
  • Auto Expo 2020
  • Home Loan
  • Business News

Trending Topics

  • Income Tax
  • income Tax Calculator
  • 7th Pay Commission
  • Reserve Bank of India
  • GST
  • Latest Business News

Follow us on

zeebiz
zeebiz

Partner Sites

  • Zee News
  • Hindi News
  • Marathi News
  • Bengali News
  • Tamil News
  • Malayalam News
  • Gujarati News
  • Telugu News
  • Kannada News
  • DNA
  • WION
© 2023. Indiadotcom Digital Private Limited. All Rights Reserved.
LIVE TV