LIVE TV
ZEE Business
ZEE BUSINESS
हिंदी में पढ़ें  हिंदी में पढ़ें
Live TV
Live TV
  • Home
  • Budget 2021
  • Personal Finance
    • PPF
    • Mutual Funds
    • Income tax
    • EPFO
    • Income Tax Calculator
    • Personal Loan Calculator
    • Car Loan Calculator
    • Home Loan Calculator
    • SIP calculator
    • SWP Calculator
    • MF Returns Calculator
    • Lumpsum Calculator
  • India
    • Companies
    • Property
    • Startups
    • Uidai
  • Economy
    • Aviation
  • Tech
    • Mobiles
    • Apps
  • Auto
    • Cars
    • Bikes
  • Markets
    • Commodities
    • Currency
  • Jobs
  • Indian Railways
  • World
    • Economy
    • Politics
    • Markets
  • videos
  • photos
  • Authors
  • More ...
    • VIDEOS
    • PHOTOS
Read in App
Business News » Companies News

Airtel, Vodafone vs Reliance Jio: Big relief as TDSAT strikes down Trai's predatory pricing rule

The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (Trai) had -- following allegations of Reliance Jio's entry tactics of life-long free voice calls and dirt cheap data constituting predatory rates -- in February defined what would constitute significant market power (SMP) that could abuse the market with a predatory pricing. These were, however, contested by old operators who felt the norms favoured Jio.

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Linkedin
  • whatapp
  • View in App
Airtel, Vodafone vs Reliance Jio: Big relief as TDSAT strikes down Trai's predatory pricing rule
TDSAT, however, pointed out that the regulator can call for details of any segmented offer about which it may receive specific complaints. Image source: Reuters
Written By: PTI
Updated: Fri, Dec 14, 2018
07:28 am
New Delhi, PTI
RELATED NEWS
TDSAT's interim order is a relief for telcos; they can offer value to customers: Rajan Mathews, COAI TDSAT's interim order is a relief for telcos; they can offer value to customers: Rajan Mathews, COAI
Jio case: CCI seeks probe report on telcos in 2 months Jio case: CCI seeks probe report on telcos in 2 months
Telecom Disputes Tribunal asks TRAI to re-examine Reliance Jio's promotional offers Telecom Disputes Tribunal asks TRAI to re-examine Reliance Jio's promotional offers
Telecom tribunal seeks clarifications from TRAI on Reliance Jio's free offers Telecom tribunal seeks clarifications from TRAI on Reliance Jio's free offers
Idea challenges TRAI's permission to Jio to extend promo offer Idea challenges TRAI's permission to Jio to extend promo offer

The telecom tribunal Thursday struck down Trai's new norms on predatory pricing saying they lacked required transparency, an order that provides much-needed relief to operators such as Bharti Airtel and Vodafone Idea who had alleged that the rules were tailored for a new entrant.

The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (Trai) had -- following allegations of Reliance Jio's entry tactics of life-long free voice calls and dirt cheap data constituting predatory rates -- in February defined what would constitute significant market power (SMP) that could abuse the market with a predatory pricing. These were, however, contested by old operators who felt the norms favoured Jio.

In a strongly-worded order, the Telecom Disputes Settlement and Appellate Tribunal (TDSAT) said that Trai could not impose financial disincentives and ordered it to rework the predatory pricing rules within six months.

"The impugned tariff amendment order is set aside in so far as it changes the concept of SMP (significant market power), non-predation and the related provisions," TDSAT Bench comprising Justice SK Singh and member AK Bhargava said in an order dated December 13, 2018.

It further added: "...The impugned decisions on the issue of SMP and predation cannot be sustained for the reasons of lacking the required transparency".

The tribunal further held that segmented offers and discounts in ordinary course of business to existing customers without any discrimination do not amount to a tariff plan and therefore "need no reporting in manner prescribed for regular tariff plans". This means operators would not be duty-bound to disclose to the regulator, the details of such tailormade offerings typically meant to retain customers.

TDSAT, however, pointed out that the regulator can call for details of any segmented offer about which it may receive specific complaints.

Trai, in its contentious February order, had tweaked the definition of significant market power to state only players with substantial revenue and subscriber base could potentially abuse market with predatory pricing. The earlier criteria also took into account high volume of traffic. An operator would be liable to cough-up a penalty of up to Rs 50 lakh per telecom circle, if a tariff was found to be predatory.

Jio's introductory offer of free voice and data in 2016 had generated massive traffic on its network, which was largely sustained when it started charging for data at nominal rates last year.

Trai's changed rules had sparked-off a furore in the industry. Older and established telecom carriers had alleged that the order virtually permitted a telecom service provider, an "effective significant market player", to indulge in predatory pricing to the severe detriment of others.

In its ruling on Thursday, TDSAT observed that it would not be proper to adopt a definition which provides artificial protection to an operator who may have the capability and intent to destabalise the sector through predatory pricing before it attains the defined status of SMP.

"If a new entrant needs to be protected from the rigours of non-predation, it can be done through the provisions like "Welcome Offer" and promotional scheme as availed by Reliance Jio...But to allow freedom from requirements of non-predation till acquisition of 30 per cent of total activity in a given market prima facie appears to be an extreme step and unnecessary abdication of its regulatory powers by Trai in the context of tariff conditions and their enforcement," TDSAT said.

It further said that powers and jurisdiction of a statutory authority like the Competition Commission should not be blocked or abridged by issuing order or directions like those impugned which do not have the flavour of a subordinate legislation such as regulations.

When contacted, Trai said it is looking at the telecom tribunal's ruling and may appeal in the Supreme Court if it found any "legal issues for deliberation".

"We are looking at the order by TDSAT, and are examining the issues...Prima facie there seems to be certain law points for deliberation and if that is so, we may go to the SC," Trai Secretary S K Gupta said.

Get Latest Business News, Stock Market Updates and Videos; Check your tax outgo through Income Tax Calculator and save money through our Personal Finance coverage. Check Business Breaking News Live on Zee Business Twitter and Facebook. Subscribe on YouTube.

TAGS:
TDSATAirtelVodafoneTelecom
RELATED NEWS
TDSAT's interim order is a relief for telcos; they can offer value to customers: Rajan Mathews, COAI TDSAT's interim order is a relief for telcos; they can offer value to customers: Rajan Mathews, COAI
Jio case: CCI seeks probe report on telcos in 2 months Jio case: CCI seeks probe report on telcos in 2 months
Telecom Disputes Tribunal asks TRAI to re-examine Reliance Jio's promotional offers Telecom Disputes Tribunal asks TRAI to re-examine Reliance Jio's promotional offers
Telecom tribunal seeks clarifications from TRAI on Reliance Jio's free offers Telecom tribunal seeks clarifications from TRAI on Reliance Jio's free offers
Idea challenges TRAI's permission to Jio to extend promo offer Idea challenges TRAI's permission to Jio to extend promo offer

LATEST NEWS

Pensioners ALERT: RUSH! Last date to submit digital life certificate tomorrow—Avail doorstep service from SBI, PNB, BoB and other banks

Covid 19 2nd phase vaccination drive from March 1: EXPLAINED! Who are eligible, required photo identity, advance self-registration—All you need to Know

7th Pay Commission Latest News: Check out these vacancies notified by UPSC; salary up to Rs 1,77,500 plus DA and other allowances

ISRO First Mission in 2021: Indian rocket to launch Brazilian satellite, PM Modi picture on spacecraft, space privatisation and more

Oil drops on dollar strength and OPEC+ supply expectations

Stock Market Outlook: Nifty, Bank Nifty crucial levels REVEALED; Anil Singhvi explains key reasons behind massive fall

Bank Holidays March 2021: RBI says banks will remain closed on these many days next month

Indian economy 2021: With 0.4% GDP growth in 3rd quarter, country out of technical recession

Sovereign Gold Bond Scheme 2021: Issue Price fixed at Rs 4,662/gm

IIT Bombay releases GATE 2021 answer key—This is how you can check and raise objection

  • India News
  • World News
  • Companies News
  • Market News
  • Personal Finance News
  • Technology News
  • Automobile News
  • Small Business News
  • Income Tax Calculator
  • Live TV
  • Videos
  • Photos
  • Author
  • Rss Feed
  • Advertise with us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Legal Disclaimer

Latest Trending Updates

  • EPFO
  • Budget 2020
  • Income Tax Return
  • Auto Expo 2020
  • Home Loan
  • Business News

Trending Topics

  • Income Tax
  • income Tax Calculator
  • 7th Pay Commission
  • Reserve Bank of India
  • GST
  • Latest Business News

Follow us on

zeebiz
zeebiz

Partner Sites

  • Zee News
  • Hindi News
  • Marathi News
  • Bengali News
  • Tamil News
  • Malayalam News
  • Gujarati News
  • Telugu News
  • Kannada News
  • DNA
  • WION
Copyright © Zee Media Corporation Ltd. All rights reserved