LIVE TV
ZEE Business
ZEE BUSINESS
हिंदी में पढ़ें  हिंदी में पढ़ें
Live TV
Live TV
  • Home
  • Personal Finance
    • PPF
    • Mutual Funds
    • Income tax
    • EPFO
    • Income Tax Calculator
    • Personal Loan Calculator
    • Car Loan Calculator
    • Home Loan Calculator
    • SIP calculator
    • SWP Calculator
    • MF Returns Calculator
    • Lumpsum Calculator
  • India
    • Companies
    • Property
    • Startups
    • Uidai
  • Economy
    • Aviation
  • Tech
    • Mobiles
    • Apps
  • Auto
    • Cars
    • Bikes
  • Markets
    • Commodities
    • Currency
  • Jobs
  • Indian Railways
  • World
    • Economy
    • Politics
    • Markets
  • videos
  • photos
  • Authors
  • More ...
    • VIDEOS
    • PHOTOS
Read in App
Business News » World News

Massive California verdict expands J&J's talc battlefield

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Linkedin
  • whatapp
  • View in App
Updated: Wed, Aug 23, 2017
03:32 am
Reuters
RELATED NEWS
Monetary Policy announcements exhibit continuity and stability - Expert Ajay Bagga tells Anil Singhvi Monetary Policy announcements exhibit continuity and stability - Expert Ajay Bagga tells Anil Singhvi
RBI Monetary Policy Review: Shaktikanta Das led panel keeps policy rates unchanged RBI Monetary Policy Review: Shaktikanta Das led panel keeps policy rates unchanged
Infosys Chairman Nandan Nilekani on India's Digital Economy I Kotak Institutional Equities highlights details Infosys Chairman Nandan Nilekani on India's Digital Economy I Kotak Institutional Equities highlights details
Digital economy to outpace GDP growth, will result in 'competitive advantage period' for leaders in digital space highlights ICICI Securities Digital economy to outpace GDP growth, will result in 'competitive advantage period' for leaders in digital space highlights ICICI Securities
#GSTMakeItEasy: Facing GST related issues? Big initiative by Zee Business - Tweet your problems now! Check all details here #GSTMakeItEasy: Facing GST related issues? Big initiative by Zee Business - Tweet your problems now! Check all details here

A massive California verdict in a lawsuit alleging Johnson & Johnson`s talc-based products cause cancer has opened a new front in the litigation, upending the company`s hopes that the cases were only gaining traction in Missouri, legal experts said.

The $417 million award by California jury to a California resident suggested so-called forum-shopping, in which parties seek to file cases in whichever jurisdictions seem most favourable, may not be the main problem facing J&J as it wrestles with some 4,800 outstanding talc lawsuits.

J&J, which denies any link between talc and cancer, said in a statement it would appeal Monday`s verdict but declined further comment.

That verdict was more than the sum of all the previous talc awards, which totalled $307 million and were meted out by juries in the same state court in St. Louis, Missouri, in cases filed by out-of-state residents. A fourth of talc lawsuits nationally were brought in St. Louis after the first large verdicts there.

J&J has cast the St. Louis court as overly plaintiff-friendly and has focussed on getting the cases brought by out-of-state plaintiffs dismissed.

"This has very much been about forum shopping," Howard Erichson, a professor at Fordham School of Law, said about the talc trials. "The fact that there has been a big verdict in California is definitely interesting."

Monday`s verdict in Los Angeles Superior Court came in a case involving a 63-year-old woman who claimed she developed ovarian cancer from using Johnson`s Baby Powder for feminine hygiene since childhood.

Corporations have long fought against plaintiffs filing lawsuits in courts favourable to them, and a U.S. Supreme Court ruling in June delivered them a big victory, holding that state courts cannot hear claims against companies not based in the state when the alleged injury did not occur there.

J&J appeared to be an immediate beneficiary of that ruling, which a St. Louis judge cited in declaring a mistrial in a talc case involving two out-of-state women.

The company also said it believed the Supreme Court decision required the reversal of the four St. Louis verdicts.

But legal experts said the verdict in the California case, in which venue was not an issue, could shift the focus back to the evidence.

J&J shares did not react to the verdict. The company has so far not announced a litigation reserve for talc cases and analysts have said they would not be concerned until that happened.

The first talc award against J&J was handed down in St. Louis state court in February 2016, with the jury ordering J&J to pay $72 million.

The company prevailed in only one of the four talc trials that followed in the same court, with the other verdicts ranging from $55 million to $110 million.

The company has decried the St. Louis court for allowing plaintiffs to present expert testimony linking talc products with cancer that the company contends is speculative and scientifically unsound. It has appeals pending on those grounds.

J&J has contrasted the Missouri court`s stance to a New Jersey state court ruling in September 2016 that disqualified plaintiffs` experts, leading to the dismissal of two talc cases. The plaintiffs` appeal of that ruling is pending.

The Los Angeles judge allowed the testimony of some of the same plaintiffs` experts as in St. Louis.

The California jury seemed to react similarly to the evidence, said Diane Lifton, a defence lawyer not involved in the talc case.

"Something clearly inflamed the jury again," she said.

Nathan Schachtman, a product liability defence lawyer, said the California verdict showed that, venue issues aside, the evidence against J&J was compelling.

"I think it`s a tough case for the defence," he said.

(This article has not been edited by Zeebiz editorial team and is auto-generated from an agency feed.)

Get Latest Business News, Stock Market Updates and Videos; Check your tax outgo through Income Tax Calculator and save money through our Personal Finance coverage. Check Business Breaking News Live on Zee Business Twitter and Facebook. Subscribe on YouTube.

TAGS:
Economy
RELATED NEWS
Monetary Policy announcements exhibit continuity and stability - Expert Ajay Bagga tells Anil Singhvi Monetary Policy announcements exhibit continuity and stability - Expert Ajay Bagga tells Anil Singhvi
RBI Monetary Policy Review: Shaktikanta Das led panel keeps policy rates unchanged RBI Monetary Policy Review: Shaktikanta Das led panel keeps policy rates unchanged
Infosys Chairman Nandan Nilekani on India's Digital Economy I Kotak Institutional Equities highlights details Infosys Chairman Nandan Nilekani on India's Digital Economy I Kotak Institutional Equities highlights details
Digital economy to outpace GDP growth, will result in 'competitive advantage period' for leaders in digital space highlights ICICI Securities Digital economy to outpace GDP growth, will result in 'competitive advantage period' for leaders in digital space highlights ICICI Securities
#GSTMakeItEasy: Facing GST related issues? Big initiative by Zee Business - Tweet your problems now! Check all details here #GSTMakeItEasy: Facing GST related issues? Big initiative by Zee Business - Tweet your problems now! Check all details here

LATEST NEWS

CBSE CISCE Board Exams 2021 POSTPONED: Class 10 class 12 board exam candidates must know these IMPORTANT points - check here

Kisan Vikas Patra scheme offers 6.9 pct interest; Which other schemes are offering HIGHER INTERESTS - Know here

Irdai imposes Rs 51 lakh penalty on 4 insurers

JEE Main April Exam 2021 postponed; NTA says revised dates to be announced 15 days prior to exam

Stocks in Focus - ACC, Bajaj Consumer, ICICI Prudential, Crisil, Alok Industries - Q4 results to be announced on Monday; stocks likely to remain in focus

Stocks in Focus on April 19: Macrotech Developers, HDFC Bank, Mindtree, Pharma Stocks to KEC International; here are the 5 Newsmakers of the Day

Railways to run Oxygen Express to meet demand during Covid 19; Green Corridor being created to facilitate movement of these trains

Facebook privacy breach - Lesson for Organisations to learn from this

Gold Price Today 18-04-2021 – Be prepared to pay more for Gold, Silver; not just coronavirus, bullion prices may jump because of THIS reason

NEW LISTING TODAY: Macrotech Developers IPO to list today on the exchanges, Know what Investors should do

  • India News
  • World News
  • Companies News
  • Market News
  • Personal Finance News
  • Technology News
  • Automobile News
  • Small Business News
  • Income Tax Calculator
  • Live TV
  • Videos
  • Photos
  • Author
  • Rss Feed
  • Advertise with us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Legal Disclaimer

Latest Trending Updates

  • EPFO
  • Budget 2020
  • Income Tax Return
  • Auto Expo 2020
  • Home Loan
  • Business News

Trending Topics

  • Income Tax
  • income Tax Calculator
  • 7th Pay Commission
  • Reserve Bank of India
  • GST
  • Latest Business News

Follow us on

zeebiz
zeebiz

Partner Sites

  • Zee News
  • Hindi News
  • Marathi News
  • Bengali News
  • Tamil News
  • Malayalam News
  • Gujarati News
  • Telugu News
  • Kannada News
  • DNA
  • WION
Copyright © Zee Media Corporation Ltd. All rights reserved