LIVE TV
ZEE Business
ZEE BUSINESS
हिंदी में पढ़ें  हिंदी में पढ़ें
Live TV
Live TV
  • Home
  • Budget 2021
  • Personal Finance
    • PPF
    • Mutual Funds
    • Income tax
    • EPFO
    • Income Tax Calculator
    • Personal Loan Calculator
    • Car Loan Calculator
    • Home Loan Calculator
    • SIP calculator
    • SWP Calculator
    • MF Returns Calculator
    • Lumpsum Calculator
  • India
    • Companies
    • Property
    • Startups
    • Uidai
  • Economy
    • Aviation
  • Tech
    • Mobiles
    • Apps
  • Auto
    • Cars
    • Bikes
  • Markets
    • Commodities
    • Currency
  • Jobs
  • Indian Railways
  • World
    • Economy
    • Politics
    • Markets
  • videos
  • photos
  • Authors
  • More ...
    • VIDEOS
    • PHOTOS
Read in App
Business News » Personal Finance News

Planning to churn your portfolio to save on LTCG tax? Think again!

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Linkedin
  • whatapp
  • View in App
Planning to churn your portfolio to save on LTCG tax? Think again!
The reason the taxes are higher if one holds for a longer period is because you are paying tax on a larger amount as the gains are higher. Image source: Pixabay
Written By: ZeeBiz WebTeam
Updated: Wed, Feb 07, 2018
11:33 am
ZeeBiz WebDesk
RELATED NEWS
Post Office Schemes: Good news for savings account holders! Withdrawal limit hiked from Rs 5,000 to Rs 20,000 at these branches Post Office Schemes: Good news for savings account holders! Withdrawal limit hiked from Rs 5,000 to Rs 20,000 at these branches
Good news for six crore EPFO members! check how much your Provident Fund (PF) will grow after EPF interest rate for FY21 announced Good news for six crore EPFO members! check how much your Provident Fund (PF) will grow after EPF interest rate for FY21 announced
LIC Jeevan Umang Insurance Policy: GUARANTEED benefits! NO LIMIT on maximum basic sum assured - All details here LIC Jeevan Umang Insurance Policy: GUARANTEED benefits! NO LIMIT on maximum basic sum assured - All details here
EPF interest rate 2020-21: ANNOUNCED! Check latest PF news update on EPFO provident fund deposits EPF interest rate 2020-21: ANNOUNCED! Check latest PF news update on EPFO provident fund deposits
Insurance alert! Big decision by Modi government to facilitate resolution of complaints - All you need to know Insurance alert! Big decision by Modi government to facilitate resolution of complaints - All you need to know

By Rajeshwari Adappa

Everybody hates taxes and investors are no exception. Many are searching for ways to either avoid or minimise the long-term capital gains (LTCG) tax.

One of the ideas being touted is to churn the investment portfolio annually. But will the selling and buying of shares/units of mutual funds help investors to avoid or reduce their tax outgo? Also, would the amount of taxes saved by the annual churning be worth the trouble in the long run?

It is felt that many brokerage houses may encourage their investors to churn their portfolios to save on taxes. “We are likely to see some churn happening. Many investors will be advised to churn. Especially in the case of mutual funds, investors will be advised to get out of dividend option and choose the growth option,’’ points out P V Subramanyam, chartered accountant and financial trainer.

But experts are unanimous in their view that churning the portfolio, just to save taxes, is not beneficial for investors. The churning strategy is flawed, feels Vidya Bala, head, mutual fund research, FundsIndia. “It focuses on tax paid instead of net returns made. It does not account for the lower overall return by churning and investing,’’ points out Bala.

Incidentally, this strategy of selling and buying again each year to save taxes is contrary to the long-held view that equity investments fetch the best returns if they are held for long periods.

“Unnecessarily churning the investment portfolio is counter-productive. Rather, investors should focus on generating returns out of their portfolios,’’ points out Deven Choksey, promoter, KRChoksey.

“It is a wrong strategy for mutual fund investors as they will lose out on returns,’’ says Bala.

Assuming pre-tax rate of return at 12%, if a corpus of Rs 25 lakh is invested for a period of 10 years and each year the person books profit in such a way that the capital gains is Rs 1 lakh and reinvests the sale proceeds again, then the person would be left with a post-tax corpus of Rs 70.81 lakh. However, if the same person does not churn the portfolio but chooses to remain invested, then they end up with a corpus of Rs 72.27 lakh.

“The investor who chooses to hold ends up with a return of 11.2% while the investor who keeps churning the portfolio will end up with a return of 10.9%,’’ points out Bala.

The tax is higher at Rs 5.37 lakh in the case of the hold strategy and lower at Rs 5.09 lakh in the case where the portfolio follows the churn strategy. But do not get carried away by the lower taxes.

Remember, the lower taxes is due to the lower gains.

The reason the taxes are higher if one holds for a longer period is because you are paying tax on a larger amount as the gains are higher.

One ends up paying lower taxes in cases where the portfolio is churned constantly. “But that is because you have a lower corpus, thanks to the churning,’’ explains Bala.

One needs to look at the net returns on the portfolio, rather than look at tax outflows alone. “One should take a holistic view. What’s the point if one is left with less money in hand?” asks Bala.

The reason for the lower returns is that by making constant changes to the investment portfolio, investors lose the advantage of starting from a low base. “The investor loses out on the benefit of compounding and buying at a low NAV (net asset value),’’ says Bala.

“The churning strategy may not work for mutual fund investors but it could work for those investing in stocks. However, even that is theoretically possible only if one buys stocks at a lower level each time,’’ says Bala.

In order to buy stocks at low prices, one would have to do a lot of research, which is not possible for the common retail investors. Also, investors need to bear in mind that churning the portfolio annually would involve a lot of paperwork and effort.

Firstly, one would need to calculate the tax outgo and sell the assets in such a way that the LTCG works out to about Rs 1 lakh or so. Then, one has to reinvest the amount into assets for the second year. All this would require a lot of research and paperwork.

The amount of tax saved may just not be worth the effort, especially since the tax saved is at the cost of earnings.

(Source: DNA Money)

Get Latest Business News, Stock Market Updates and Videos; Check your tax outgo through Income Tax Calculator and save money through our Personal Finance coverage. Check Business Breaking News Live on Zee Business Twitter and Facebook. Subscribe on YouTube.

TAGS:
Personal FinanceLTCG taxInvestment PortfolioLTCG impact on mutual fundsStocks
RELATED NEWS
Post Office Schemes: Good news for savings account holders! Withdrawal limit hiked from Rs 5,000 to Rs 20,000 at these branches Post Office Schemes: Good news for savings account holders! Withdrawal limit hiked from Rs 5,000 to Rs 20,000 at these branches
Good news for six crore EPFO members! check how much your Provident Fund (PF) will grow after EPF interest rate for FY21 announced Good news for six crore EPFO members! check how much your Provident Fund (PF) will grow after EPF interest rate for FY21 announced
LIC Jeevan Umang Insurance Policy: GUARANTEED benefits! NO LIMIT on maximum basic sum assured - All details here LIC Jeevan Umang Insurance Policy: GUARANTEED benefits! NO LIMIT on maximum basic sum assured - All details here
EPF interest rate 2020-21: ANNOUNCED! Check latest PF news update on EPFO provident fund deposits EPF interest rate 2020-21: ANNOUNCED! Check latest PF news update on EPFO provident fund deposits
Insurance alert! Big decision by Modi government to facilitate resolution of complaints - All you need to know Insurance alert! Big decision by Modi government to facilitate resolution of complaints - All you need to know

LATEST NEWS

CBSE Class 10, Class 12 date sheet revised—check new time table, instructions here

ESIC Recruitment 2021 Notification: Apply online at esic.nic.in for 6552 vacancies to be filled for UDC and Stenographer Posts

PUBG Mobile India update: Important message from Krafton! India relaunch soon? Check here

Call of Duty Mobile vs Garena Free Fire comparison: Here's all you need to know about these battle royale games

Trinamool candidate list West Bengal Election 2021: TMC chief Mamata Banerjee announces candidates for 291 seats, to contest from Nandigram; See FULL LIST

7th Pay Commission latest news today: Big Holi gift for Central government employees! Center issues this notification on 7th CPC leave rule

Covid 19 new guidelines released - check new orders for religious places, malls, restaurants and more

TMC Candidates List 2021 - Names of 291 candidates announced for West Bengal Elections; See Complete List Here

Aadhaar card-based driving licence service: Check step by step guide to renew your driving licence online without going to RTO

Trinamool candidate list 2021: Over 20 MLAs, ministers dropped from TMC candidacy for upcoming Assembly polls

  • India News
  • World News
  • Companies News
  • Market News
  • Personal Finance News
  • Technology News
  • Automobile News
  • Small Business News
  • Income Tax Calculator
  • Live TV
  • Videos
  • Photos
  • Author
  • Rss Feed
  • Advertise with us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Legal Disclaimer

Latest Trending Updates

  • EPFO
  • Budget 2020
  • Income Tax Return
  • Auto Expo 2020
  • Home Loan
  • Business News

Trending Topics

  • Income Tax
  • income Tax Calculator
  • 7th Pay Commission
  • Reserve Bank of India
  • GST
  • Latest Business News

Follow us on

zeebiz
zeebiz

Partner Sites

  • Zee News
  • Hindi News
  • Marathi News
  • Bengali News
  • Tamil News
  • Malayalam News
  • Gujarati News
  • Telugu News
  • Kannada News
  • DNA
  • WION
Copyright © Zee Media Corporation Ltd. All rights reserved