Investor vs Trader: Who really makes more money in the long run? Explained with examples

Investor vs Trader: When it comes to the stock market, one question never gets old — who makes more money, an investor or a trader? Both aim to earn profits from the market, but their styles, time horizons, and risk levels are completely different. Here’s a simple explainer.

The basic difference

Investor: An investor buys stocks with a long-term view — usually for years or even decades. The idea is to benefit from business growth, dividends, and compounding returns.

Add Zee Business as a Preferred Source

Trader: A trader, on the other hand, looks to make profits from short-term price movements — sometimes within a day, week, or month.

How they make money

Investors earn through long-term capital appreciation and dividends. They rely on the power of compounding — allowing profits to generate more profits over time.

Traders earn by taking advantage of market volatility. They buy low and sell high within short time frames. Some even use technical analysis or chart patterns to spot quick opportunities.

Example 1: The long-term investor

Suppose you invested Rs 1 lakh in Infosys in 2000. As of 2025, that investment would be worth over Rs 25 lakh, including dividends and stock splits. That’s the power of long-term compounding — the business grew, and so did your wealth.

Example 2: The short-term trader

Now take a trader who bought Infosys at Rs 1,500 and sold it at Rs 1,550 in a week — making a 3 per cent gain. If they repeat such trades successfully throughout the year, they can earn good returns — but this requires time, discipline, and accuracy.

Who wins in the long run?

Most studies and market experts agree — investors generally make more money in the long run. Markets tend to grow over time as economies expand and businesses create value.

However, successful traders can outperform investors in shorter periods, but only a small percentage manage to do this consistently. Frequent trading also comes with higher taxes, brokerage costs, and stress.

Expert take

Market experts like Warren Buffett often say, “The stock market is a device for transferring money from the impatient to the patient.”

This perfectly sums up why long-term investors usually come out ahead — patience and compounding work in their favour.

Bottom line

- Both approaches can make money, but your choice depends on your risk appetite, time, and mindset.

- If you prefer steady, long-term growth, investing is the better path.

- If you enjoy fast decisions and daily market action, trading might suit you — but it demands skill and discipline.

- In the long run, investors usually build wealth, while traders chase profits. The market rewards both — but only if you know your style and stick to it.