Nomura warns against govt's stimulus package; blames fiscal stress on higher spending

Nomura says it may be counterproductive this time if the government uses a stimulus package to help the economy on the growth track.

Nomura warns against govt's stimulus package; blames fiscal stress on higher spending
Arun Jaitley speaking at a Ficci conference. Photo: IANS
By PTI
Updated: Wed, Sep 27, 2017
09:27 am
Mumbai, PTI
RELATED NEWS
How will Modi's economic stimulus impact Indian economy? How will Modi's economic stimulus impact Indian economy?
Govt stimulus to boost economy in the works Govt stimulus to boost economy in the works
Economic stimulus on its way but where should it be spent? Economic stimulus on its way but where should it be spent?
India considering $7.7 billion stimulus spending in 2017/18: government sources India considering $7.7 billion stimulus spending in 2017/18: government sources
Asian central banks hold their own after Fed signals stimulus rollback Asian central banks hold their own after Fed signals stimulus rollback

Key highlights:

  • Nomura India has warned the present macro problems are due to higher spending and not lack of it
  • It also says it is not due to low revenue receipts and hence a pump priming maybe counterproductive this time around
  • Noting that the current fiscal trends suggest spending is to blame, not revenue, she said revenue collection for April-July was only 2.1 % below the historical run- rate, but better than in recent years

Amid reports of a fiscal stimulus to boost the sagging economy, a foreign brokerage has warned the present macro problems are due to higher spending and not lack of it and also not due to low revenue receipts and hence a pump priming maybe counterproductive this time around.

"The fiscal stress is more a result of excess spending thus far, which has not left much room for spending in the remaining months: it can rise only 1.5% y-o-y in August-March versus 23.1% in April-July to meet the FY18 budgeted spending target.

"Therefore, a fiscal stimulus may not be so much to boost growth as to prevent a bigger drag," Nomura India chief economist Sonal Verma has said in a report.

Noting that the current fiscal trends suggest spending is to blame, not revenue, she said revenue collection for April-July was only 2.1 % below the historical run- rate, but better than in recent years.

"We expect some revenue shortfall on telecom receipts, disinvestment and dividends, but the buoyancy in direct tax collections suggests the overall revenue miss should not be large. Despite teething issues, GST should lead to higher revenues as it has been inflationary," she said.

Expenditures, on the other hand, are off the charts, with the Central government spending 7.5 % above the historical run-rate, the report said.

The government has spent 37.7 % of its budgeted target, even exceeding the 2008/09 run-rate (the year of stimulus), to offset the impact of note ban and GST, said the brokerage.

ALSO READ: