DMart and Reliance Retail: Food & Grocery | From a disruptor’s lens
Capital dumping is likely to take center-stage going forward. Global/domestic retailers Amazon, Walmart-backed Flipkart and Reliance Retail have significantly strengthened their war chests for investments in supply chain, fulfillment capabilities and pricing/selection. An inkling of this can already be seen in the reducing selection/pricing arbitrage of DMART over these biggies.
Capital dumping is likely to take center-stage going forward. Global/domestic retailers Amazon, Walmart-backed Flipkart and Reliance Retail have significantly strengthened their war chests for investments in supply chain, fulfillment capabilities and pricing/selection. An inkling of this can already be seen in the reducing selection/pricing arbitrage of DMART over these biggies. Fulfilment/supply chain investments of Amazon’s F&G unit (adj. for scale) are already >6x that of DMART’s (Comparison: DMART Ready vs Amazon). Former remains aggressive on footprint expansion. HDFC Securities maintain SELL recommendation on DMART with a DCF-based target price of Rs 2160/sh.
The view from a disruptor’s lens is a salivating one as short of a few well-capitalised operators, the organised Food & Grocery ecosystem remains:
(1) profitless
(2) cash-strapped
(3) supported by increasing crutches (high gross margins, inefficient cost structures and increasing vendor support)
See Zee Business Live TV Streaming Below:
HDFC Securities read-through across the ecosystem suggests:
(1) the phase of capital dumping by global/domestic biggies may soon be upon us
(2) selection/pricing arbitrage vis-a-vis industry bellwether DMART continues to shrink
(3) margin cracks are imminent
(4) Reliance Retail – Future Retail combination could change the complexion of competition in top Indian districts..
Margin crack for ecosystem is imminent:
Over FY15-20, despite low competitive intensity, most organised grocers’ sales velocity (1-4% CAGR) has undershot inflation, signaling a gradual but structural footfall reduction.
(1) Most continue to hide behind high gross margins as cost of retailing remains inefficient
(2) have bare-bone investments in online fulfilment capabilities. Moreover, as subsidised home delivery becomes table stakes, even the best (D-MART) may get arm-twisted into bringing a part of online fulfillment costs on their books (not factored in, remains a risk to estimates).
Thus, the imperative to remain competitive (reducing GMs) + rising cost of retailing is likely to crack operational margins for the ecosystem over FY21-25.This has played out globally too (Walmart’s CY15-20 margin crack).
Reliance + Future Retail > DMART in store density:
Post integration and, if executed well, the Reliance Retail + Future Retail store network is likely to get nearly as dense as DMART’s in the latter’s key markets (HDFC Securities Estimate: 48% of DMART’s stores, 65-70% of revenue). These markets are the most populated/over-retailed districts in India with high PCI. Hence, the rise in competitive intensity/price action and near-zero sourcing margin arbitrage seems to be a foregone conclusion. The high population density in these districts could help fulfill JioMART orders within controlled costs too.
Survivors don’t offer any margin of safety:
While consolidation in F&G is imminent, survivors (DMART) do not offer any margin of safety at 75x+ FY23 P/E. DMART’s growth is likely to be healthy (21/23/23% revenue/EBITDA/PAT CAGR), largely underpinned by network expansion. Alas, pressure on sales velocity and margins remains probabilistically high as deep-pocketed operators enter DMART’s key catchments.
HDFC Securities maintain SELL recommendation on DMART with a DCF-based target price of Rs 2160/sh – implying 34x FY23 EV/EBITDA + 2x FY23 sales for e-comm.
Note: HDFC Securities currently have an SOTP-based fair value of Rs 3743bn for Reliance Retail, implying 20x FY23 EV/EBITDA + 3x FY23 sales for its e-commerce business.
Get Latest Business News, Stock Market Updates and Videos; Check your tax outgo through Income Tax Calculator and save money through our Personal Finance coverage. Check Business Breaking News Live on Zee Business Twitter and Facebook. Subscribe on YouTube.
RECOMMENDED STORIES
10:46 AM IST